Skip to content


Your cart is empty

Article: How to Break in Loafers Fast: Step-by-Step Guide Breaking in Loafers

How to Break in Loafers Fast: Step-by-Step Guide Breaking in Loafers

How to Break in Loafers Fast: Step-by-Step Guide Breaking in Loafers

The appeal of Italian loafers is undeniable. They’re stunning, sophisticated, and versatile shoes that can elevate your look - whether you’re headed to a weekend brunch with loved ones, preparing for a long day of work, or looking to make a statement at a wedding or formal event.

Style aside, though, much of what has kept loafers relevant for more than a century is their comfort and fit. That being said, this is only possible when you go about breaking in loafers correctly. The last thing you want is to spend your hard-earned money on the best Italian shoes only to end up underwhelmed by how they actually feel on your feet. 

If you find yourself getting sore feet or worse, developing blisters, it could be that your shoes haven’t had the chance to break in just yet. So, we’ve decided to help you make the most of our footwear investment by piecing together this complete guide on how to break in loafers fast. 

This is a blend of art and science. And below, we’ll unravel the secrets of transforming a stiff pair of loafers into a comfort haven for your feet, all while preserving the aesthetics that made you fall in love with them in the first place.

You're about to discover a wealth of knowledge that could make the difference between merely owning loafers and truly experiencing them. So, let’s start with a crucial first question to set the stage for the rest of our conversation: should I break in loafers at all?

Should I Break in Loafers? The Break in Period Explained

The moment you bring home a new pair of loafers, you are embarking on an intimate journey, a dance that begins with the first timid steps and culminates in a harmonious, perfect fit. 

We know you’re eager to get these on your feet and wear them to your workday, or unveil them at a wedding. Not so fast, though - this could spell disaster in terms of your happiness and comfort. Before you wear them for a long period like this, you need to give them an opportunity to mold to your feet and settle in.

This journey is fondly known as the 'break-in period'. It's an essential step, a ritual you may want to rush but should instead savor, as it leads to an undeniable bond between you and your loafers.

What Does 'Breaking in Shoes' Mean?

Breaking in new loafers essentially means allowing the shoe to mold and adapt to the unique contours and movements of your foot. When a loafer is first crafted, it is firm and holds a generic shape.

However, with each wear, the material slowly stretches, flexes, and softens, allowing the shoe to take on a personalized form that aligns seamlessly with your foot's anatomy.

As such, we have a complete guide on breaking in wedding shoes, too. And today, we’re taking this a step further by explaining how to break in leather loafers in particular. Why is this so important, though?

Why Breaking in Loafers is Important

The importance of breaking in loafers cannot be overstated. Imagine stepping into your loafers and feeling an intimate familiarity as they embrace your feet like a custom-made glove - almost as if they were made just for you. No pinching, no rubbing, just effortless comfort - that's the magic of a well-broken-in pair of loafers.

Neglecting this crucial step can lead to discomfort, painful blisters, and even long-term foot problems. Moreover, it can detract from your overall experience with the loafers, turning a potential love affair into a relationship of convenience or even regret.

Breaking in loafers is not just about comfort, though. It's about the longevity of the shoe as well. Properly broken-in loafers distribute pressure evenly, reducing strain on the materials and thus extending the shoe's lifespan. This means certain areas on the sole won’t wear out quicker than others - you’ll get to love your loafers for even longer.

So remember, each step taken in the break-in process is a step towards a comfortable, enjoyable, and long-lasting relationship with your loafers. And with that being said, let’s take a look at how to break in loafers fast.

How to Break in Loafers Fast: Step-by-Step Guide to Breaking in Loafers 

Now that we've explored why breaking in your loafers is essential let's dive into what you came here for today: to discover how to break in loafers fast. Here are some practical steps to ensure that your loafers form a comfortable fit for your feet in the quickest, most effective way possible. Stay tuned for more advice on maximizing the comfort of your new loafers afterward.

The Importance of Patience and Gradual Wearing

The breaking-in process begins with patience. It may seem tempting to wear your new loafers all day, but resist the urge. This is a sure-fire way to end up with sore, blister-ridden feet.

Start by wearing them around the house for an hour or two each day. Gradually increase this time as your shoes start to stretch and form to your feet. It's a delicate balance of introducing your loafers to their new home (your feet) while also sparing your feet from the discomfort of a shoe that's still getting to know them.

If you do this for a few hours a day, it shouldn’t take more than a week or so before your loafers are ready for longer voyages out of the house. More on the timeline for breaking in new loafers later. First, let’s talk socks.

Using Thick Socks to Stretch Your Loafers

Thick socks can be your secret weapon when breaking in loafers. Simply wear a pair of thick socks, then slip into your loafers and walk around the house. The socks will add pressure to the sides of the shoes, encouraging them to stretch. Remember to do this for short periods initially, gradually increasing the time as your shoes begin to loosen. Eventually, you’ll be able to wear your normal socks.

Making Use of Shoe Stretchers

If patience isn't your virtue, consider investing in a shoe stretcher. They can expedite the breaking-in process by gently expanding your loafers without the potential discomfort of wearing them. Insert the stretcher into your loafers, adjust it to apply a mild stretch, and leave it overnight. By morning, your loafers will be one step closer to that ideal fit.

The Magic of Freezing

Here's a surprising tip: fill sealable bags with water, place them inside your loafers, and then put your loafers in the freezer overnight. As the water freezes, it expands, stretching your shoes in the process. This method might sound unconventional, but it's effective if you’re in a rush and don’t have shoe stretchers.

However, it's crucial to ensure that the bags are fully sealed to avoid water damage to your shoes. This is not something we recommend unless it’s an absolute emergency and you need your loafers broken in overnight. And, on that note, how long does it take to break in loafers?

How Long Does it Take to Break in Loafers?

The time it takes to break in your loafers depends on the specific materials used and the initial fit of the shoe. However, with regular, careful effort, most loafers will start to break in and feel more comfortable within a week or two. 

During this time, remember to treat both your loafers and your feet with kindness, and you'll soon have a pair of shoes that feel like they were custom-made for you. While you’re undoubtedly eager to debut your new shoes out of the house, patience is a virtue. And believe us when we say the wait is worth it!

Beyond Breaking in Loafers, Here are More Tips on Maximizing Comfort and Fit

There you have it - how to break in loafers fast. Armed with these tips on breaking in leather loafers, you are well on your way to enjoying your new shoes to the fullest. But, our journey doesn't stop at breaking in your loafers. There are many ways to ensure you maximize comfort and achieve that glove-like fit. Let's explore these avenues.

Get Your Sizing Right

This one sounds obvious - but getting your loafer sizing right from the start can obviously influence whether a break-in period is necessary or not - and the degree to which your shoes need to be broken in. When trying on loafers, your toes should not feel cramped, and your heels should not slip out of the shoe as you walk. 

Obviously, you cannot try on your shoes if you’re shopping online, which is why we encourage you to read our complete guide on Italian shoe sizing. Or, better yet, consider getting your feet measured professionally to ensure you are selecting the right size for your loafers.

Proper Loafer Care

Taking good care of your loafers can also enhance comfort. Shoe trees can also be used when you're not wearing your loafers to help maintain their shape. 

Regular cleaning helps to maintain the integrity of the leather or suede, ensuring your loafers stay supple and mold well to your feet. Our resource on how to clean loafers is an invaluable guide in preserving your investment for the long haul.

Opting for Shoe Inserts

Consider shoe inserts as custom interior upholstery for your loafers. They can enhance cushioning, offer targeted arch support, and mold to the curves of your foot, all while making your loafers feel snug and personalized. For those days when you plan to be on your feet longer, they can be a true game-changer.

Choosing the Right Socks

Yes, here at Del Toro, we recommend wearing your loafers with socks. This prevents odors from taking hold within your shoe while improving your comfort. 

But, you shouldn’t just wear any socks. Socks can either elevate or dampen your loafer experience. A breathable, thin pair can wick away moisture, keeping your feet dry and odor-free, especially in warm weather. 

For colder days, thicker socks provide a comforting cocoon of warmth without compromising style. A sock isn't merely an accessory but a pivotal element in your overall loafer comfort.

Shopping at Del Toro From the Jump

One cannot overemphasize the importance of starting your loafer journey with quality at its heart. And that's where Del Toro enters the scene. Our men’s Italian loafers or women’s Italian loafers are crafted based on the history of the penny loafer - honoring the traditions of classic Italian shoemaking. 

It’s rare to find a pair of shoes that are as comfortable as they are stunning - but that’s what you’ll uncover at Del Toro. All our footwear is handmade with a dedication to craftsmanship, are an exquisite blend of comfort, style, and durability. 

Designed to contour to your feet, they aim to make the breaking-in period as effortless as a Venetian gondola ride. Our promise is that you’ll love these shoes on the 1,000th wear as much as the 1st wear.

And, we have so many styles to choose from - leather or suede, classic penny loafers or a more modern style we’ve developed. You can shop based on the season - check out our lists of the best summer loafers, best spring loafers, or the best fall loafers. And then, get your Italian shoes handmade today at Del Toro. You won’t regret it.

Wrapping Up Our Guide on How to Break in Loafers

That concludes our guide on how to break in loafers. From understanding the concept of breaking in loafers to an array of ways to maximize comfort and fit, we’ve shared our knowledge and expertise in hopes to enhance your loafer experience. Remember, a well-fitted loafer is more than just a shoe - it's an extension of you, your style, and your love for comfort. 

If you’d like to explore more resources we have on maximizing the experience of loafers, learn about how to wear loafers with jeans - or how to style loafers in general. You can also figure out which of the different types of loafers is right for your blog.

And remember - at Del Toro, you’ll find more than just loafers. We also have men’s velvet slippers and Italian men’s sneakers, along with women's velvet slippers and women's Italian sneakers. House slippers, dress shoes, we’ve got it all for you.

So, what are you waiting for? Upgrade your shoe game or get started breaking in loafers today. May every step in your Del Toro loafers mirror a tailored fit and supreme comfort!

Read more

Meet Christian Hafer

Meet Christian Hafer

Welcome to The Rivista, a place where we highlight unique and creative members of the Del Toro community who inspire us. Since Father’s Day is just around the corner, this month’s edition is a spot...

Read more
Driving Shoes vs Loafers

Driving Shoes vs Loafers: What are the Differences & Which Style is Right For You?

It's a conundrum that has bewitched footwear enthusiasts and style-conscious individuals for years: driving shoes vs loafers. Which is the right style for you?  At first glance, they may seem quite...

Read more