Skip to content


Your cart is empty

Article: What Color Loafers Should I Get?

What Color Loafers Should I Get?

What Color Loafers Should I Get?

You know you want to add loafers to your wardrobe, but you’re not sure which of the loafer colors to go with. This is an age-old conundrum every shoe aficionado has wrestled with.

What color loafers should I get to ensure my wardrobe is well-rounded? Which color best suits my style preferences and personality? We’ll help you find an answer in this guide.

The shade of your loafers can whisper subtleties about your personality, command attention in a room, or subtly elevate a casual outfit to something more sophisticated. With myriad colors available, each promising its unique flair, the decision can be as daunting as it is exciting.

But, one thing is for sure amidst all this uncertainty - the best loafers for men and women alike are just a click away at Del Toro. we have a diverse range of colors so you can find the perfect pick for your personality, preferences, and existing collection.

We’ll explain what makes us the #1 choice for Italian shoes for sale online later. First, let’s highlight the role of loafer colors to show you why this decision can’t be taken lightly…

The Role of Loafer Colors in Your Wardrobe

The shoes you wear are statements. Loafers occupy a cherished spot in the wardrobes of well-dressed men and women alike with their elegant design and slip-on convenience. But it’s not just the style, it’s also the color that defines their essence in your wardrobe.

Color and First Impressions: The Power of Perception

Ever noticed how a bright red loafer catches the eye before a muted brown one? Colors play a pivotal role in shaping perceptions. The hue of your loafers can convey confidence, elegance, playfulness, or conservatism. 

For instance, darker shades often emanate a sense of formality and authority. In contrast, brighter or unconventional colors might suggest creativity and a willingness to step outside the box. 

Choosing the right color is, thus, a reflection not only of your outfit but of the impression you wish to make. Whether you’re looking to wear loafers with a suit or you are considering how to style loafers for women, color coordination should be top of mind.

The Interplay Between Outfit Colors and Shoe Colors

While we often hear about matching our shoes with belts or other accessories, the more nuanced coordination is between your outfit and your loafer's shade. 

A charcoal gray suit paired with black loafers exudes a classic appeal, while the same suit with deep burgundy loafers adds a touch of adventurous sophistication. 

The rule isn't rigid, but understanding color palettes and contrasts can help in curating looks that resonate. This is also true whether you’re wondering how to wear loafers with shorts or how to wear loafers with jeans.

Elevating or Toning Down Your Look with Loafer Colors

Loafers have this innate ability to adapt. A crisp white shirt and navy chinos can be instantly elevated with tan loafers for that Sunday brunch. 

Conversely, a pair of neutral-colored loafers, say in beige or gray, can provide that grounding element. This is ideal if you're looking to tone down a particularly loud outfit.

Remember, it's not always about standing out. Sometimes, the power lies in understated elegance, and your loafer color choice can be the key to achieving that balance. So, what color loafers should I get?

So, What Color Loafers Should I Get?

The significance of your loafer’s colors cannot be overlooked. In a perfect world, you’d have a different color for every day of the week - but that’s not always feasible.

Sure, you can add to your collection slowly over time. But what color loafers should I get first? We’ll talk about the most common colors along with the most versatile loafer color below to help you make a confident decision.

What are the Most Common Loafer Colors?

There are a seemingly endless number of loafer colors - but we’ll just highlight the most popular below to show you what’s available:

  • Black: Classic, timeless, and formal. Perfect for business settings or formal events.
  • Brown: Ranging from light tan to dark chestnut, brown loafers are versatile and can suit both casual and semi-formal occasions.
  • Navy: An elegant alternative to black, navy can be equally formal but adds a touch of uniqueness.
  • Burgundy: Offering a rich hue, burgundy loafers stand out without being overly flashy, ideal for those wanting a pop of color in a sophisticated manner.
  • Grey: Subtle and understated, grey loafers are great for those who prefer neutrality without opting for black.

These common colors are just the tip of the iceberg. You can also find more niche colors like cognac, birch, dark green, white, tan, and beyond. That being said, which is the most versatile loafer color?

Which is the Most Versatile Loafer Color?

Brown is your best bet if versatility is what you're aiming for. A medium shade of brown specifically can transition smoothly from day to night, from casual outings to business meetings. Pair them with jeans, chinos, or even suits - brown loafers seldom disappoint.

Or, if you already own a brown pair of loafers, consider a black pair. You can coordinate your loafers with virtually any outfit when you have both black and brown at your disposal. However, you should always account for your unique personality and preferences when choosing loafer colors…

Color Choices Based on Personality and Preferences

Your choice of loafer color should ultimately resonate with who you are and how you want to be perceived. Here are a few thoughts to ponder before you place your order:

  • Sticking with black or brown ensures that you're always in vogue if you’re the type who leans towards traditional and classic styles.
  • Conversely, experimenting with colors like green, burgundy, or even patterned loafers can be exciting if you're someone who loves making bold statements.
  • Softer shades like beige or light blue can be ideal for the easy-going individual who treasures casual aesthetics.
  • So, what color loafers should I get? If we had to leave you with one takeaway, it would be this: the best loafer color is the one that you feel most confident and authentic in

    But before we introduce you to our diverse array of loafer colors at Del Toro, let’s talk about some other things you should account for in your shopping endeavors…

    More Considerations Beyond Loafer Colors: Material, Style, etc.

    While color undeniably sets the tone for your loafers, it’s just one facet of a multi-dimensional decision process. From the texture of the material to the intricacies of style and design, let’s delve into these pivotal considerations.

    Material Matters: Suede vs Leather

    There are really just two materials you can choose from in a loafer: suede or leather. Here are the unique characteristics of each:

    • Suede: Soft, velvety, and with a matte finish, suede brings a luxurious yet relaxed feel. It's particularly enticing in lighter colors like beige or taupe, making it a top choice for casual and summer looks. However, suede demands careful maintenance, especially in unpredictable weather. Our guide on how to clean loafers made from suede is a great asset.
    • Leather: Loafers made from this material are timeless and durable. They exude sophistication. You can find them in a variety of finishes from glossy patent to matte. While black and brown are the conventional choices, don’t shy away from exploring vibrant dyed leathers for a more contemporary vibe. Learn how to clean leather shoes or how to break in leather shoes in our blog.

    The Influence of Loafer Styles on Color Choices: Penny, Tassel, and More

    You’ll also need to determine which of the different types of loafers most closely resonates with your personality and style preferences. Here are the most common:

    • Penny Loafers: These are traditionally a more casual design that can be adventurous in color. Think shades like olive or caramel for a trendy, yet rooted look. Learn more about what makes them special in our guide to the penny loafers' history.
    • Tassel Loafers: These have a playful charm thanks to their distinct tassels. While they look splendid in classic shades, burgundy or navy can add a modern twist without compromising their inherent elegance.
    • Moccasin Loafers: With their laid-back vibe, moccasins in lighter shades like sand or light gray can be the quintessential summer companion.

    How Details and Embellishments Play With Color

    Embellishments can significantly influence the color choice, whether in the form of subtle stitching or standout metalwork. 

    Brightly colored loafers with too many embellishments might seem too busy, overshadowing the rest of your outfit. On the other hand, simple black loafers with intricate designs can become the conversation starter at any event. 

    It’s all about balance - if the design is elaborate, lean towards neutral colors. If the design is minimal, feel free to explore a broader color palette. And, whichever loafers you decide to go with, there is only one place worth shopping for the best Italian shoes: Del Toro Shoes.

    All the Best Loafer Colors are Available at Del Toro: Your Trusted Source for Luxury Italian Loafers Online!

    Del Toro is your trusted source for both men’s Italian loafers and women’s Italian loafers. We’ve curated a collection of luxury Italian loafers in an array of styles, materials, and colors - meaning your perfect pair is just a few clicks away.

    These aren’t just stunning shoes, they’re comfortable. You’ll love wearing them no matter how long you spend on your feet. This is a result of our commitment to honoring the traditions of Italian shoemaking. Our footwear is brought to life by skilled artisans in the heart of Italy using the finest materials available.

    From timeless classics like deep blacks and rich browns to vibrant multi-color masterpieces that add unparalleled flair, we've got you covered. Whether you're looking for loafers in summer or loafers for fall, you’ll find something that catches your eye.

    And, we have other types of Italian shoes for women and Italian shoes for men, too. That includes velvet men’s slippers, men’s tuxedo slippers, men’s Italian sneakers, Italian sneakers for women, women’s velvet slippers, and more. 

    So, what are you waiting for? Explore our catalog and see which color loafers steal your heart!

    Final Thoughts on What Color Loafers You Should Get

    Choosing the right loafer colors is more than a fashion statement. It's an extension of your personality and style. From understanding the deep-rooted connections between colors and perceptions to recognizing the role of materials and styles in your choices, the journey to finding your perfect loafer is a thoughtful one.

    So, what color loafers should I get? Only you can answer that question! But, we’ve armed you with the insights to do so with confidence, so it’s time to get to shopping.

    Our blog has more resources to help you make the most of your new shoes. If you are struggling with how to keep loafers from slipping off, learn how should a loafer fit, how to convert the Italy shoe size to US, or consider wearing loafers with socks

    We also have guides on how to clean velvet shoes, when to wear loafers, what to wear with loafers, loafers vs oxfords, boat shoes vs loafers, are loafers business professional, shoes to wear with tuxedo (our tuxedo loafers are a great choice), picking your groom shoes, and more.

    Otherwise, find the best loafer colors at Del Toro today. Every shade you could envision, every texture you want to feel, and every design that resonates with your soul awaits you in our online storefront!

    Read more

    Meet Cale Darrell

    Meet Cale Darrell

    For this month’s Rivista, we caught up with one of Chicago’s best vintage curators and brand owners, Cale Darrell. Cale is always on the go, digging through bins and second hand stores one day...

    Read more
    Where to Buy Italian Shoes Online

    Where to Buy Italian Shoes Online

    Italian shoes stand as a testament to time-honored craftsmanship and unparalleled elegance. There is truly nothing like them - both in terms of aesthetics and comfort.  But, not all Italian shoes a...

    Read more