Skip to content


Your cart is empty

Article: Loafers vs Oxfords: What is the Difference, and Which is Right For You?

Loafers vs Oxfords

Loafers vs Oxfords: What is the Difference, and Which is Right For You?

As a connoisseur of refined taste, you understand the importance of making a lasting impression, and your choice of shoes plays a crucial role in achieving that. The quest for the perfect pair often brings one to the great debate: loafers vs oxfords?

Both options hold a revered place in the pantheon of timeless footwear, but at Del Toro, we believe that there is a clear winner between the two. And as you may already know, the right choice can elevate your style to dazzling heights. 

In this guide, we'll delve into the rich history and distinct characteristics of loafers and oxfords, before revealing why we believe loafers are the ultimate choice for well-styled gentlemen and ladies alike.

As you immerse yourself in the world of Italian luxury, prepare to discover the perfect blend of sophistication and comfort that will not only make you feel confident in your appearance but also leave an indelible mark on those you encounter. 

So, allow us to be your trusted companion in your journey to find the perfect footwear. You’re in good hands at Del Toro! We’ll start by taking a trip back in time to unpack the history of oxfords vs loafers.

What is the Difference Between Loafers and Oxfords?

Understanding the subtle differences between loafers and oxfords is essential for those who strive to be at the forefront of fashion. 

As we offer a history lesson on these two types of shoes, and demystify the defining characteristics they each have, you'll gain a deeper appreciation for the craftsmanship and design that set them apart. 

Let’s start with our personal preference in the loafers vs oxfords debate: the former.

Definition and History of Loafers

Loafers are distinguished by their laceless design, low-cut profile, and moccasin-like construction. They often have a low heel, allowing for easy slip-on wear, and their upper may include unique details such as decorative stitching, tassels, or metal accents. 

The absence of laces gives loafers a casual yet sophisticated look, making them suitable for a wide range of occasions and outfits. For example, you can masterfully pair loafers with a tuxedo, or you can dress up a casual outfit by learning how to wear loafers with jeans. We’ll offer more specific styling tips for this versatile footwear later on.

These stylish shoes can be traced back to the early 20th century, with roots in the Norwegian fisherman's shoe called the Aurland moccasin. Loafers eventually made their way to the United States, where they gained popularity among the American Ivy League crowd.

The iconic penny loafer, known as the Bass Weejun, was introduced in 1936, taking its name from the Norwegian town of Aurland and the American term "weejun," which was derived from "Norwegian." 

Since then, loafers have continued to evolve, with various different types of loafers emerging such as tassel loafers and horse-bit loafers, each featuring distinct design elements that contribute to their timeless appeal. Today, they’re a must-have in any man or woman’s wardrobe - and we don’t say that lightly.

You can learn more about the history of loafers in our complete guide, where we unpack the origins of penny loafers to the dominance of the Gucci loafer. For now, though, let’s pay homage to another classic footwear choice: oxfords.

Definition and History of Oxfords

Oxfords, sometimes referred to as Balmorals, are characterized by their closed lacing system, where the eyelet tabs are sewn under the vamp. This intricate detail gives them a sleek and polished appearance. 

Oxfords typically have a slim profile, a low heel, and a closed lacing system, which contributes to their formal appearance. The intricate detailing, such as broguing or cap-toe designs, further sets oxfords apart from other types of shoes.

The origins of the Oxford shoe can be traced back to the 19th century at Oxford University in England. Initially designed as a more comfortable alternative to heeled boots, oxfords quickly gained widespread appeal for their refined elegance.

Throughout the 20th century, oxfords became synonymous with formality and sophistication, often being the footwear of choice for businessmen, politicians, and those attending black-tie events. Various styles of oxfords have emerged over time, including cap-toe, wingtip, and wholecut, each defined by specific detailing and design elements.

Now - knowing a bit more about both oxfords and loafers, which of these should you add to your wardrobe? Below, we’ll give you our reasoning for why, if we had to pick just one, it would be loafers.

Loafers vs Oxfords: Which Should You Add to Your Wardrobe?

As you embark on your journey to find the perfect luxury footwear for any occasion, it's crucial to understand the unique characteristics that set loafers and oxfords apart. 

So in this section, we’ll unpack the reasons to love both styles. But then, we’ll offer up our own personal say in the matter - with some clear examples of why we believe loafers are the superior choice for fashion-forward men and women alike.

Reasons to Love Loafers

There are 3 reasons why we think loafers deserve a spot in your rotation:

  • Versatility: One of the key advantages of loafers is their incredible versatility. Their laceless design and relaxed elegance allow them to effortlessly transition from casual to semi-formal settings. You can wear loafers with dress pants, jeans, chinos, or shorts, making them a stylish statement in any ensemble.
  • Comfort: Loafers prioritize comfort without sacrificing style. The slip-on design and lack of restrictive lacing make them an ideal choice for those seeking ease of wear. Additionally, the typically wider toe box and lower heel provide all-day comfort. After all, what good is a luxury shoe if it doesn’t feel luxurious on your feet?
  • Distinct Styles: From the classic penny loafer to the sophisticated horse-bit and playful tassel loafer, there is a style to suit every personality and taste. This variety ensures that you can always find a loafer that complements your wardrobe and reflects your unique style. You’ll truly never get bored with them as you can constantly add more styles to your collection.

Reasons to Love Oxfords

Now, we want to give credit where credit is due - while they don’t hold a candle to the effortless elegance of loafers, Oxfords are a great shoe in their own regard:

  • Formality: Oxfords are the epitome of formal footwear. Their closed-lacing system and sleek profile make them the perfect choice for black-tie events, business settings, and other formal occasions. With that said, style has evolved dramatically - and these days, loafers can be pulled off in formal settings in a more exciting, eye-catching manner than oxfords can.
  • Tradition: With a rich history dating back to the 19th century, oxfords carry an air of timeless elegance and sophistication. This classic design has remained popular for generations, making oxfords a tried-and-true staple for the discerning shoe connoisseur.

But, as you’ll discover below, they just can’t compete with the loafer. Here’s why…

Why We Believe Loafers Are the Right Choice for Men & Women Alike

While both these shoes have their unique merits, only one can reign supreme in the loafers vs oxfords debate. And as we’ve hinted at multiple times throughout our conversation today, we firmly believe that loafers stand out as the superior choice for today's stylish men and women.

The unparalleled versatility of loafers makes them the perfect addition to any wardrobe, easily adapting to a wide range of settings and outfits. Furthermore, loafers don't compromise on comfort, making them an ideal choice for those who value both style and practicality. 

With a variety of distinct styles available, loafers offer endless opportunities for self-expression and individuality, allowing you to make a fashion statement that's uniquely yours.

In a world where fashion and comfort often seem at odds, loafers provide the perfect solution. They seamlessly blend sophistication, versatility, and ease of wear, making them the ultimate choice for those seeking to make a lasting impression. Embrace the allure of loafers and elevate your wardrobe with a touch of Italian luxury.

Advice on Wearing Oxfords vs Loafers: Occasions, Style Tips and Where to Shop

Before we bring this guide to a close, we want to offer some insights on where you can wear loafers vs oxfords - along with some quick style tips to help you pull off whichever type of shoe you end up going with. 

Stay tuned to the end, though, as we’re going to introduce you to your new favorite footwear brand to experience all the magic of classic Italian loafers…

Occasions Where Loafers and Oxfords Work Well

  • Loafers: The versatile nature of loafers makes them suitable for a wide range of occasions, from casual outings to semi-formal events. Are loafers professional? Yep. Are they casual? Definitely. They can be whatever you want them to be - it’s all in how you dress them up or down! Wear loafers to brunch with friends, business-casual office environments, or even a summer wedding. The key is to choose a style and material that complements the overall formality of the event.
  • Oxfords: As the epitome of formal footwear, oxfords are best suited for black-tie events, weddings, and business settings. Opt for oxfords when attending a gala, a job interview, or any other occasion that calls for a polished and sophisticated appearance. As we said earlier, though, when you really want to make an impression - it’s hard to argue against the choice of loafers!

Style Tips for Loafers and Oxfords

  • Loafers: When styling loafers, consider pairing them with tailored pants, chinos, or even dark denim for a smart-casual look. Experiment with different materials and designs to make a bold statement. For a more formal setting, opt for a sleek leather loafer with minimal embellishments. You can learn more about how to style loafers in our blog, including whether or not to wear socks with loafers.
  • Oxfords: To achieve a refined look with oxfords, pair them with a well-tailored suit or dress slacks. Pay attention to the details, such as matching your belt with your shoes and choosing dress socks that complement your outfit. For added flair, consider brogued or wingtip designs that showcase the artistry and craftsmanship of the shoe.

Explore Our Luxury Italian Loafers and Discover Firsthand Why You Need These in Your Closet!

Now that you've gained valuable insights into the world of loafers and oxfords, it's time to introduce you to Del Toro Shoes - the ultimate destination for exquisite Italian loafers. 

Our collection of premium men’s Italian loafers and women’s Italian loafers combines timeless design, exceptional craftsmanship, and the finest materials to create footwear that exudes elegance and sophistication.

Each pair of Del Toro loafers is meticulously crafted in Italy, ensuring unparalleled quality and comfort. These are shoes that don’t just turn heads and score compliments - they are comfortable even when you’re on your feet all day.

With a diverse range of styles, colors, and materials, our loafers cater to every taste and preference, allowing you to find the perfect addition to your wardrobe. For specific recommendations, read our article on the best summer loafers, the best spring loafers, or the best loafers for men year-round.

So, go ahead and indulge in the magic of Italian luxury with Del Toro’s handmade Italian shoes. Elevate your style, make a lasting impression, and experience the unparalleled allure of our exquisite loafers. Your closet will thank you.

Final Thoughts on the Oxfords vs Loafers Debate

At this point, it’s time to bring our oxfords vs loafers debate to a close. We’ve put both shoes under a microscope, giving you an up close and personal look at the subtle intricacies of loafers vs oxfords. In terms of versatility, style, comfort, and edge, loafers are the premier choice for well-dressed men and women alike.

If you want to learn more about how the different types of luxury footwear stack up against each other, you can explore our blog. We’ve built similar resources comparing and contrasting loafers vs dress shoes and loafers vs slippers

You can also learn about how to wash velvet shoes, how to clean leather shoes, and how should loafers fit in our blog. This will help you keep your new favorite footwear looking stunning for years to come and ensure you get the right size the first time around.

Otherwise, there is only one thing left to do - head over to Del Toro and get your hands on the best Italian shoes the industry has to offer. When you can’t leave the house without scoring compliments you’ll know you made the right choice.

Read more

The Best Spring Loafers for Men & Women

The Best Spring Loafers for Men & Women in 2023

Spring is here, and it’s time to refresh your wardrobe so you can leave home feeling confident and charismatic. Whether you want to take advantage of those first few warm days outdoors or you’re lo...

Read more
Loafers vs Boat Shoes

Loafers vs Boat Shoes: How are They Different & Which is Better?

Navigating the sea of footwear options can be a challenge, especially when you're faced with two equally iconic and beloved styles: loafers vs boat shoes.  This one decision will influence how you ...

Read more